In New York, there are two primary consequences of refusing to submit to a chemical test (e.g., a breath test or a blood test). First, the refusal generally can be used against you at trial as “consciousness of guilt” evidence. Second, the refusal is itself a civil violation — wholly independent of the DWI charge in criminal Court — which results in proceedings before a DMV Administrative Law Judge, and generally results in both (a) a significant driver’s license revocation, and (b) a civil penalty (i.e., a fine).
Back to Top
A chemical test refusal is considered to be a first offense if, within the past 5 years, you have neither (a) had your driving privileges revoked for refusing to submit to a chemical test, nor (b) been convicted of DWAI, DWI, Aggravated DWI, DWAI Drugs, DWAI Combined Influence (not arising out of the same incident).
The civil sanctions for refusing to submit to a chemical test as a first offense are:
A chemical test refusal is considered to be a repeat offense if, within the past 5 years, you have either (a) had your driving privileges revoked for refusing to submit to a chemical test, or (b) been convicted of DWAI, DWI, Aggravated DWI, DWAI Drugs, DWAI Combined Influence or Zero Tolerance (not arising out of the same incident).
The civil sanctions for refusing to submit to a chemical test as a repeat offender are:
In addition, DMV will require evidence of alcohol evaluation and/or rehabilitation before it will ever relicense you.
If you are under 21 and are found to have refused to submit to a chemical test as a first offense, your driver’s license will be revoked for 1 year. If you have a prior refusal or a conviction of DWAI, DWI, Aggravated DWI, DWAI Drugs, DWAI Combined Influence or Zero Tolerance, your driver’s license will be revoked for at least 1 year or until you turn 21, whichever is longer.
The license revocation for a chemical test refusal is a “civil” or “administrative” penalty separate and distinct from the license suspension/revocation, which results from a DWAI,
DWI, Aggravated DWI, DWAI Drugs or DWAI Combined Influence conviction in criminal Court. As such, the suspension/revocation periods run separate and apart from each other to the extent that they do not overlap.
In other words, to the extent that a DWAI, DWI, Aggravated DWI, DWAI Drugs or DWAI Combined Influence suspension/revocation and a chemical test refusal revocation overlap, DMV runs the suspension/revocation periods concurrently. By contrast, to the extent that the suspension/revocation periods do not overlap, DMV runs the suspension/revocation periods consecutively.
There is no simple answer (or even necessarily a correct answer) to the question of whether you should submit to a chemical test in a given situation — a question which usually arises in the middle of the night! The answer depends upon many factors, such as whether there has been an accident involving serious physical injury or death, whether the DWI charge is a felony, whether you are a repeat/multiple offender, whether you need to drive to earn a living, whether you have a commercial driver’s license, whether the test result is likely to be above the legal limit, whether there is a plea bargaining policy in the county in which you are arrested with regard to test refusals and/or BAC limits (e.g., no reduction to DWAI if the defendant’s BAC is above .13%), etc.
The following general rules represent our current opinion on this issue:
If you refuse to submit to a chemical test, you have the right to a Due Process hearing before a DMV Administrative Law Judge. Although the odds are certainly against you at the hearing, such hearings are definitely winnable — and can also provide critical information with regard to your DWI case in criminal Court (if the case is still pending).
Author of Handling the DWI Case in New York
Considered a standard reference for the defense of Driving While Intoxicated cases. (Published by Thomson/West)
Peter Gerstenzang, Esq.
Gerstenzang, O’Hern, Sills & Gerstenzang
210 Great Oaks Boulevard
Albany, New York 12203
Phone: (518) 456-6456
Fax: (518) 456-6056
Cell: (518) 441-7011
Developed ™ © 2015